Media Contact

ACLU of Florida Media Office, [email protected]

TALLAHASSEE, FL — The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Florida has filed a lawsuit on behalf of a Doral voter to compel Governor Ron DeSantis to fulfill his constitutional obligation to call a special election to fill the vacancy in Florida State Senate District 39.

The vacancy arose 84 days ago, when Senator Bryan Ávila resigned to run for lieutenant governor on August 25, 2026. For 12 weeks, the residents of District 39 have had no voice in the Florida Senate, and that silence grows louder as new legislators are sworn in today and prepare to return for interim committee weeks beginning November 30. Despite the urgency, Governor DeSantis has not called a special election.

The lawsuit, filed in the Florida Supreme Court, alleges that Governor DeSantis has violated his mandatory duty under the Florida Constitution and state law by failing to call a special election. Historically, Florida governors have typically acted within a week of a resignation to ensure timely representation for constituents. The governor’s inaction, the lawsuit contends, breaks with this precedent, effectively disenfranchising voters in Senate District 39.

“Doral and Hialeah deserve a state senator to be our voice in Tallahassee without delay,” said Alejandro Peñuela, a Doral resident and plaintiff in the lawsuit. “The governor’s refusal to call a special election denies us our right to representation and ignores decades of precedent. That hurts all of us, regardless of party. It’s anti-republican, goes against our democracy, and is wrong.”

This marks the seventh time since 2021 that voters have had to go to court to force Governor DeSantis to call a special election. On six occasions since 2021, voters have filed similar lawsuits when he failed to call elections for nine vacant legislative or congressional seats in Tampa, Palm Beach, Northwest Florida, Brevard County, Miami-Dade County, and Broward County. In each case, the governor only set those elections after the suits were filed.

“There is no good reason for this governor to keep resisting timely special elections,” stated Nicholas Warren, ACLU of Florida senior staff attorney. “From Jeb Bush to Rick Scott, prior governors consistently acted quickly to ensure Floridians retained their voice in government. Governor DeSantis’s refusal to do the same is as perplexing as it is illegal.”

The lawsuit recounts that governors prior to DeSantis often took less than five days to call special elections. Governor DeSantis routinely takes weeks and sometimes months, as in this case. Had the governor acted quickly after Senator Ávila resigned in August, a special primary or general election could have been held concurrent with already-scheduled municipal elections in late November or December. The delay is likely to cost taxpayers more to hold a separate election.

“The Legislature must enact mandatory deadlines for calling and holding special elections so that no Floridian is deprived of representation longer than necessary,” urged Kara Gross, ACLU of Florida’s policy and advocacy director. “Lawmakers should reform this broken system to ensure that citizens from Santa Rosa to Sweetwater never again lose representation because of one governor’s inaction.”

Senate District 39 covers northwest Miami-Dade County including Hialeah, Doral, Sweetwater, and Miami Lakes. The petition in Peñuela v. DeSantis can be viewed below.