Home » Our Issues » Voting Rights
Election Reform
The quest to ensure that all Florida's citizens can vote and have their votes accurately counted has led us to address a wide variety of issues, from ballot design and redistricting schemes to maintenance of voter rolls and signage in polling places. All our work is based upon the "one person, one vote" principle and the belief that voting is our most fundamental right as individuals in a democracy.
ACLU Action During the 2000 Presidential Election
During the 2000 Presidential election, the ACLU received complaints from hundreds of voters about various aspects of the state's voting process. Working in conjunction with our National Voting Rights Project, based in Atlanta, the ACLU filed "friend-of-the-court" briefs in both the Palm Beach County Circuit Court and the 4th District Court of Appeal challenging the now-infamous Palm Beach "butterfly ballot". The ACLU also filed a brief in the U. S. Supreme Court defending the authority of the Florida Supreme Court to interpret and resolve conflicts in state law, and supporting the court's ruling that permitted an extension of time for the hand recount of disputed ballots.
Only weeks after the U.S. Supreme Court's December 2000 decision ending the recounts, the ACLU joined with the N.A.A.C.P., the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, and other allies to file NAACP v. Harris, which challenged the voting irregularities and the mass disenfranchisement of the Presidential election. The lawsuit was not just about replacing the out-dated error prone voting machinery. The suit was also about addressing other irregularities - such as voters not being able to cast ballots because they were not provided with adequate language assistance at the polls or because they were erroneously listed on the voter rolls as felons when, in fact, they were not. Slowly but surely, the lawsuit resulted in positive reforms to Florida's voting process.
ACLU Action Since the 2000 Presidential Election
In the months after the 2000 Presidential election, the ACLU of Florida established itself as a watchdog for various changes in Florida's voting process. The ACLU lobbied the Florida Legislature concerning provisions of the Florida Election Reform Act of 2001 and wrote to the Department of Justice to express our concerns about new voting laws that threatened to take the African-American community and other minority communities backward in the civil rights struggle for equality at the polls. When the Legislature passed a law to post in every Florida polling place a list of so-called "Voter Responsibilities" that could have been mistaken by voters and poll workers as legal prerequisites in order to cast a ballot, the ACLU filed suit. Major v. Sawyer eventually prompted the Legislature to add a provision in the law to clarify that failure to perform any of the responsibilities could not prohibit a voter from voting.
The ACLU has continued to join with other groups to achieve common civil rights goals. Throughout 2001 and 2002, the ACLU worked with the Haitian-American Grassroots Coalition and others in an effort to try to increase the number of seats on the Miami-Dade County Commission so that there would be greater opportunity for local government to hear all of the country's diverse voices. After the disastrous September 2002 primaries in Miami-Dade County, the ACLU joined with numerous organizations and citizen activists to form the Miami-Dade Election Reform Coalition. Through the Election Reform Coalition, the ACLU successfully lobbied county officials to mail sample ballots - for the first time ever - to registered voters in Miami-Dade County and obtained extended early voting days and hours. In addition, the ACLU co-authored with the League of Women Voters of Miami-Dade County "Make Your Vote Count!" pamphlets in English, Spanish, and Creole to help voters stand up for their rights at the polls. (The pamphlets were published in the sample ballots as "Frequently Asked Questions"). Today, the ACLU of Florida, together with the Election Reform Coalition, is at the forefront of the push to achieve verified, secure, and auditable voting in Counties with touch-screen voting machines.
Press Releases
- 01-29-10 ACLU Given Green Light to Intervene on Behalf of Five Voters in Lawsuit Against Governor Crist
- 4-23-09 - ACLU Of Florida Asks Gov. Crist to Veto Anti-Democratic Voter Suppression Bills and Not To Accept Minor Amendments
- 4-22-09 - 42 Florida and National Groups Sign Letter Asking Gov. Crist to Veto Anti-Voter Bills
- 4-20-09 - CITIZEN GROUPS CALL UPON FLORIDA HOUSE SPEAKER LARRY CRETUL AND SENATE PRESIDENT JEFF ATWATER TO HALT VOTER SUPPRESSION BILLS
- 4-17-09 - Poisonous Anti-Voter Legislation Will Spur Lawsuits and Trigger Federal Intervention, ACLU Says
- 2-23-09 - MEDIA ADVISORY: Florida Advocacy Groups Meet with Secretary Browning
- 10-27-08 - Foreclosure Crisis Should Not Impact Voter Eligibility
- 9-26-08 - ACLU and Advancement Project Issue Guide to Florida?s ?No Match? Laws
- 10-15-07 - Florida Counties, Voters, and Taxpayers Headed for Another Voting Meltdown, Voters Coalition Warns
- 05-21-07 - ACLU Lauds New Florida Voting Law; Calls for Additional Measures
- 05-03-07 - ACLU APPLAUDS FLORIDA LEGISLATURE ON SCRAPPING FLAWED VOTING MACHINES
- 04-26-07 - Watch, Take Action, Forward: VIRAL VIDEO CAMPAIGN LAUNCHED TO SUPPORT GOVERNOR CRIST'S ELECTION REFORM PLAN
- 02-08-07 - Sarasota Voters Ask for Emergency Relief to Prevent Destruction of Election Evidence
- 02-01-07 - GOVERNOR'S ELECTION TECHNOLOGY PLAN IS STEP IN RIGHT DIRECTION, FALLS SHORT OF VOTERS' NEEDS
- 01-30-07 - ACLU Issues Statement on Governor Crist's Decision to Recommend Scrapping Touch-Screen Voting Machines
- 01-24-07 - Sarasota Voters File Pleadings Opposing Attempt by Supervisor of Elections to Compromis Election Evidence
- 01-09-07 - Voter-Plaintiffs Join Jennings Emergency Petition In Florida Appellate Court
- 12-20-06 - FLORIDA HEADED FOR 2008 ELECTION DEBACLE
- 12-19-06 - Hearing Scheduled for Today and Wednesday in Independent Sarasota Voters' Lawsuit
- 12-5-06 - Voter-Verified Paper Trail Resolutions Supported by ACLU
- 11-21-06 - SARASOTA VOTERS FILE LAWSUIT FOR REVOTE IN CONGRESSIONAL RACE
- 11-16-06 - ACLU Calls on Florida's Legislature to Increase Oversight of Electronic Voting, Require Recount Capacity
- 6-17-05 - ACLU Urges Governor to Veto Election Reform Bills
- 11-09-04 - Groups Disappointed by Federal Court Ruling Upholding Rejection of Late Miami-Dade, Broward Absentee Ballots
- 11-04-04 - Federal Court Orders Elections Officials to Preserve Absentee Ballots Received After Election Day
- 11-02-04 - Civil Rights Groups Sue to Ensure that Absentee Ballots in Dade, Broward are Counted
11-01-04 - ACLU Issues "What to Do If Challenged" Fliers to Inform Voters on Election Day
11-1-04 - Launches Video Poll Monitoring to Document Voter Challenges, Complaints of Voter Harassment
10-8-04 - Civil Rights Groups Ask Florida Supreme Court to Strike Down Provisional Balloting Restrictions
10-6-04 - Coalition Voices Concerns Over Touch-screen Voting Systems
10-5-04 - ACLU Threatens to Sue Elections Chief Glenda Hood for Disqualifying Valid Voter Registration Forms
9-17-04 - ACLU Testifies on Florida's Voting Problems Before U.S. Commission on Civil Rights
8-27-04 - ACLU Applauds Court Decision in Manual Recount Lawsuit
8-26-04 - ACLU of Florida Issues Voter Empowerment Cards to Inform Voters of Their Rights at the Polls
8-5-04 - Flaws with Touch-Screen Voting Systems Demonstrate Need for Independent Audit
7-7-04 - Groups Challenge State Rule Prohibiting Manual Recounts on Touch-Screen Voting Systems
- 6-29-04 - Voting Reform Group Calls on Governor to Order an Audit of Florida Voting Systems
- 6-7-04 - ACLU Urges County Elections Supervisors to Implement a Four-Part Program to Protect the Right to Vote
- 5-14-04 - ACLU Urges County Elections Supervisors to Verify State's Felon Matching Records to Prevent Wrongful Purging of Eligible Voters
- 4-23-04 - ACLU Asks Appeals Court to Reverse Lower Court Ruling Dismissing Paper Trail Lawsuit Filed in State Court by Congressman Robert Wexler
- 3-8-04 - ACLU Statement on Federal Paper Trail Lawsuit Filed by Congressman Robert Wexler
- 2-5-04 - ACLU Seeks to Intervene in Palm Beach County Verified Voting Lawsuit
- 11-25-02 - Findings on Miami-Dade Elections Show Improvements Still Needed, Coalition Says
- 11-5-02 - ACLU Urges Broward Elections Supervisor to Deliver Backup Voting Machines, Use Paper Ballots to Avoid Gridlock During Peak Voting Hours
- 10-29-02 - ACLU Urges Dade Election Officials to Include Sample Creole Ballots in Countywide Mailing to Households
- 11-4-02 - ACLU Urges Voters to Call Toll-free Hotline to Report Election Day Voting Problems
- 10-21-02 - Analysis of September 10th Voting Fiasco in Miami Dade Demonstrates Disproportionate Impact on Racial Minorities, ACLU Says
- 9-20-02 - Community Leaders Demand Countywide Election Reforms Prior to November Election
- 9-11-02 - ACLU Condemns Latest Florida Voting Fiasco, Warns November Elections Will Be Worse
- 9-3-02 - Settlement Reached in Florida Election Lawsuit; Punch Card System Continues to Face Scrutiny Nationwide
- 5-28-02 - ACLU Urges Court to Set Standards for Touch-Screen Voting to Safeguard Voters' Rights in Disputed Palm Beach Election
- 2-20-02 - Miami Federal Court Hearing Set for Thursday in ACLU Lawsuit Challenging Illegal Voting Methods in Town of Manalapan
- 1-25-01 - Citing Voters' Right to be Heard, ACLU Files Lawsuit Charging Illegal Voting Methods in Town of Manalapan
- 11-5-01 - Going to the Polls and Not Sure What Your Rights Are? The ACLU of Florida's Voting Rights Flier Now on the Web
- 8-20-01 - DOJ Asks for More Information on Florida Equal Voting Rights Concerns with Florida Election Reform Act
- 8-15-01 - Civil Rights Groups Sue to Halt Sections of the 2001 Florida Electoral Reform Package
- 7-19-01 - Florida Equal Voting Rights Project Urges Department of Justice to Object to Portions of Electoral Reform Package
- 6-5-01 - ACLU Statement on Report By Civil Rights Commission
- 4-27-01 - ACLU Urges Legislative Leaders to Revise Voter's Rights and Responsibilities in Election Reform Legislation
- 2-1-01 - ACLU-FL Launches Equal Voting Rights Project to Address Irregularities, Reform Election Practices in Florida
- 1-10-01 - NAACP and National Civil Rights Groups File Florida Voting Rights Lawsuit to Eliminate Discriminatory Voting Practices
- 5-12-00 - Race Discrimination Alleged in Glades County Election Methods
Legal Documents
Absentee Ballot Ruling by Judge Alan Gold (Issued Nov. 9, 2004)
Motion for Temporary Injunction in Absentee Ballot Lawsuit (filed Nov. 2, 2004)
Temporary Restraining Order in Absentee Ballot Lawsuit (issued Nov. 3, 2004)
Lawsuit on Behalf of Overseas Voter Disqualified from Voting Absentee (.pdf)
Declaration of Plaintiff David B. de Treville (Re: Overseas Voting by Absentee)
Florida Supreme Court Amicus Brief Re: Provisional Balloting Law (.pdf)
Florida Supreme Court Motion to File Re: Provisional Balloting Law (.pdf)
Florida Supreme Court Petition Regarding Provisional Balloting Law (.pdf format)
ACLU of Florida et al. v. Florida Department of State (manual recount lawsuit)
Congressman Robert Wexler vs. Theresa LePore, etc. el al (ACLU of Florida friend-of-the-court brief in paper trail lawsuit).
- Diamond et al. v. Town of Manalapan et al. (Lawsuit challenging unlawful and unconstitutional voting districting scheme in Town of Manalapan, Florida)
- Major v. Sawyer (Suit challenging sections of the 2001 Florida Election Reform Act)
- NAACP v. Katherine Harris, et al. (Complaint in class action lawsuit challenging discriminatory voting practices in Florida)
- George W. Bush v. Palm Beach County Canvassing Board, (Case filed in the United States Supreme Court)
- Thompson v. Glades County Board of County Commissioners (complaint alleging race discrimination in Glades County election methods)
Resources
- ACLU Letter with Comments on Proposed Rule No. 1S-2.041
- ACLU Letter Urging Bush to Veto House Bills 1567 and 1589
- What to Do If Challenged on Election Day
- Snipes Letter Re: Election Day Voting Problems (Oct. 29, 2004)
- Snipes Letter Re: Missing Absentee Ballots (Oct. 27, 2004)
- ACLU Provisional Balloting Report Issued October 12, 2004
- Hood Demand Letter Re: Incomplete Registrations (October 5, 2004)
- Testimony of Courtenay Strickland Before the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights (9-17-04)
- June 2004 ACLU Letter to Edward C. Kast, Division of Elections
- May 2004 Letter from Edward Kast to County Elections Supervisors
- Make Your Vote Count! (Miami-Dade) English
- Post-Election Report on the November 5th Elections in Dade
- Report on September 2002 Voting Problems
- Letter to Oliphant regarding long lines on Election Day
- Letter to Oliphant regarding Election Day problems with a Hollywood Precinct
- July 2002 Letter Urging Department of Justice to Object to Portion of Florida Law That Modifies Voting List Procedures
- July 2001 Letter Urging Department of Justice to Object to Portions of Florida's Electoral Reform Package
- November 2001 Letter to DOJ on Florida Electoral Reform
- Letter Urging Florida House Speaker Tom Feeney to Revise Election Reform Legislation
- Statement of ACLU of Florida Executive Director Howard L. Simon addressing minority voter disfranchisement
- Voting Rights Act Protections Flier
- "Case of the Month" on NAACP v. Harris et al. (class action suit addressing statewide election reform)
- "Case of the Month" on the Glades County voting discrimination case
- Briefing paper on racial justice


